Wild vs Island Bakery
An independent side-by-side comparison of Wild and Island Bakery across certifications, average sustainability score and product range.
Wild
90/100 avg score
4 products tracked
Certifications
Island Bakery
Higher score90.7/100 avg score
3 products tracked
Certifications
Top Wild products
Wild Natural Deodorant Balm Orange + Bergamot is a high-performing, vegan, and plastic-free deodorant that offers 24-hour protection while using only skin-safe, natural ingredients.
The Wild Natural Refillable Deodorant Starter Pack is a top-tier eco-friendly choice for UK consumers seeking a plastic-free, aluminium-free, and highly effective vegan deodorant.
A stylish, zero-plastic waste deodorant system featuring a reusable aluminum case and compostable bamboo pulp refills.
The Wild Natural Solid Deodorant Refill Starter Pack is a sustainable, plastic-free hygiene solution that offers 24-hour protection with a stylish reusable aluminium case.
Top Island Bakery products
Island Bakery
Island Tantaliser Organic Fairtrade Cocoa Powder
A premium, ethically sourced organic cocoa powder from the Isle of Mull-based Island Bakery. It features Fairtrade ingredients and is produced using renewable energy, making it a sustainable choice for ethical bakers.
Island Bakery
Island Bakery Organics Lemon Melts
Island Bakery Organics Lemon Melts are premium, organic vegan biscuits crafted on the Isle of Mull using renewable energy, offering a zesty, indulgent citrus flavour.
Island Bakery
Island Bakery Organic Lemon Melts
Island Bakery Organic Lemon Melts are premium vegan biscuits from the Isle of Mull, offering a zesty, buttery texture powered by renewable wind and water energy.
Frequently asked: Wild vs Island Bakery
Which is more ethical, Wild or Island Bakery?+
Island Bakery scores higher on independent Pickly scoring: Wild averages 90/100 vs Island Bakery at 90.7/100.
Which has more certifications?+
Wild appears with 6 verified certifications (Vegan, Cruelty-Free, B Corp, Plastic Free, FSC Certified). Island Bakery appears with 6 (Soil Association Organic, Fairtrade, Vegan, Vegetarian Society Approved (Vegan), FSC Certified).
Are these scores independent?+
Yes. Both brands are scored by the same methodology — never paid placement. See our methodology page for the weighting.